What Is Misrepresentation in Insurance Claims?

Last updated Tuesday, December 12th, 2023

A worried older woman on the phone sitting in her kitchen

Imagine you’re involved in a car accident, and when you file your insurance claim, the insurance company denies it due to a misrepresentation in your application. This scenario is more common than you might think, highlighting the importance of understanding “what is misrepresentation in insurance”. Let’s unveil the truth about misrepresentations and their consequences, so you can avoid such unpleasant surprises.

Understanding Misrepresentation in Insurance

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to the provision of false or inaccurate information, either deliberately or inadvertently, which can influence the insurance company’s decision-making process. Providing false information can lead to severe consequences, such as denied claims, policy cancellation, and even criminal charges for insurance fraud. Examples of misrepresentation can be found in home and life insurance applications, emphasizing the need for honesty and accuracy.

In the insurance industry, there are two types of misrepresentation: negligent misrepresentation, and fraudulent or intentional misrepresentation. Each type carries different consequences, and understanding the difference is key to safeguarding your insurance coverage.

Types of Misrepresentation

Negligent misrepresentation occurs when incorrect information is provided to the insurance provider without malicious intent. For example, a policyholder might mistakenly report the age of their home’s roof, resulting in a higher premium.

Fraudulent misrepresentation, on the other hand, involves knowingly providing false information or concealing relevant information with the intention of deceiving an insurance provider. For example, if a policyholder falsely denies prior insurance claims on their application. Fraudulent misrepresentation is the most severe form and can lead to harsh consequences, including legal repercussions.

Did Your Insurance Company Delay, Underpay, or Deny Your Claim?

Let's Get You Compensated! Call The Best Texas Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer For a FREE Case Review to Know What Your Case Is Worth.

Material Misrepresentation

Not all misrepresentations, whether negligent or fraudulent, have the same consequences. Under Texas law, the misrepresentation must be material.  A material misrepresentation is defined as a falsehood or omission regarding a significant or essential matter, also known as a material fact, in the insurance context. For example, when applying for life insurance, failing to disclose a pre-existing medical condition that increases the risk of early death such as a prior cancer diagnosis could constitute a material misrepresentation. Such misrepresentations can greatly impact an insurer’s risk assessment and potential claims.

Providing false information about your property’s condition in a home insurance application could be another example of material misrepresentation. Identifying these false statements can result in denied claims, and policy termination, and could potentially lead to criminal charges for insurance fraud.

The Consequences of Material Misrepresentation

The consequences of a material misrepresentation in insurance can be severe and far-reaching. Denied claims, policy cancellation, and legal repercussions are all potential outcomes of providing false information to an insurance provider. Insurance companies rely on accurate information to assess risk and determine appropriate coverage and premiums. Material misrepresentations made intentionally can hinder this process, potentially causing substantial financial losses for both insurers and policyholders.

Recognizing the various types of misrepresentation and their repercussions is necessary to protect your insurance coverage and avoid potential legal problems. We will now examine the specific repercussions of insurance material misrepresentations.

Denied Claims

Denied claims are a common consequence of misrepresentation in insurance. Approximately 10% of insurance claims are denied annually due to misrepresentation, with life and health insurance being the most vulnerable to claim denials. An insurance claim may be denied due to misrepresentation when the insured has deliberately concealed or provided false information on their application. However, insurance companies might use any incorrect response, whether made intentionally or not, to justify claim denial. It is possible to appeal or file suit for claims that have been denied due to misrepresentation.

Policy Cancellation

Policy cancellation is another potential consequence of misrepresentation in insurance. If an insurer discovers misrepresentations during their investigation, they may notify the policyholder of their intent to cancel the policy. The cancellation process typically involves the following steps:

  1. Detection of misrepresentation
  2. Investigation
  3. Notification of intent to cancel
  4. Opportunity to respond
  5. Final decision and cancellation

A policyholder can challenge an insurance policy cancellation on the grounds of misrepresentation. However, cancellation of an insurance policy due to misrepresentation can have a significant impact on the policyholder’s ability to acquire insurance in the future. Insurance companies may view a canceled policy as a warning sign, potentially leading to higher premiums or denial of coverage by other insurance companies.

Legal Repercussions

Fraudulent misrepresentation, such as providing false information on an insurance application or inflating a claim, can lead to legal repercussions, including insurance fraud charges. By understanding the distinction between innocent or negligent and fraudulent misrepresentations, and providing accurate information on insurance applications, you can avoid the potential legal repercussions associated with fraudulent misrepresentation.

Two people upset in an office setting

The Contestability Period in Insurance Policies

The contestability period is a specific time frame during which insurers can deny claims due to misrepresentation, typically lasting two years from the policy’s start date. The contestability period provides insurance companies with an opportunity to investigate applications for any intentional errors or misrepresentations within a certain time frame following policy approval.

Although the contestability period generally lasts two years, some exceptions may vary the duration depending on the state and the terms of the insurance policy. Let’s explore the definition, duration, and impact of the contestability period on insurance claims.

Definition and Duration

The contestability period is a set duration, usually two years, during which insurers can scrutinize claims for misrepresentation. This period allows the insurer to investigate the policyholder’s application for any misrepresentations or fraud. Should the policyholder pass away within the contestability period, the insurer has the right to dispute the claim based on any discovered intentional or fraudulent material misrepresentations.

The duration of the contestability period can vary among different types of insurance, but it is typically one to two years. Understanding the contestability period and its impact on your insurance claims is important.

Impact on Claims

During the contestability period, claims can be denied or policies rescinded if intentional and material misrepresentations are discovered. Although the exact frequency of insurance claims being denied during the contestability period due to material misrepresentations is not readily available, being aware of this period and providing accurate information on your insurance application can help you avoid potential claim denials and policy rescission.

Preventing Material Misrepresentation in Insurance Applications

Avoiding material misrepresentation in insurance applications is vital for both the policyholder and the insurer. To ensure accurate information is shared and understood, it is important to:

  1. Provide accurate information on the application.
  2. Maintain open communication with insurers.
  3. Facilitate clear and transparent communication. By following these steps, the chances of misunderstandings or deliberate misrepresentation can be diminished.

Taking the time to verify details before submitting an application or claim, and maintaining regular communication with your insurer, can help you avert misrepresentation and its possible repercussions.

Accurate Information

Supplying correct information is key to avoiding making a material misrepresentation in insurance applications. Always double-check details before submitting an application or claim to ensure the information you provide is correct and complete. 

Insurance companies also employ various methods to validate the information provided in an insurance application, including:

  • Underwriting processes
  • Consumer reports
  • Data validation tools
  • Verification through external sources such as medical records

By ensuring the accuracy of the information you provide, you can avoid potential material misrepresentations and their consequences.

Communication with Insurers

Effective interaction with insurers is crucial in averting insurance misrepresentation. Effective communication ensures that precise and comprehensive information is provided during the application process, helping to avoid material misrepresentations and fraudulent claims. Ongoing communication between insurers and policyholders can also assist in detecting and addressing any potential misrepresentations or changes in risk throughout the policy term.

Real-Life Examples of Misrepresentation in Insurance

Real-life examples of misrepresentation in insurance can be found in home and life insurance policies. We will now look at some specific instances of misrepresentation in home and life insurance to further underscore the necessity for precise information and transparent communication with insurers.

Home Insurance

Misrepresentation in home insurance can involve providing false information about the property’s condition, occupancy, or value. For example, a homeowner may fail to disclose that their basement has a history of flooding, or that they’ve rented out a room to a tenant. These omissions can result in denied claims, policy cancellation, and increased premiums.

To prevent misrepresentation in home insurance, it’s important to:

  • Supply precise details about your property’s condition, occupancy status, and value during the application process
  • Communicate openly with your insurer
  • Ask questions to ensure you understand the requirements and potential consequences of misrepresentation.

Life Insurance

Life insurance misrepresentation can occur when applicants provide false information about their health, lifestyle, or income to a life insurance company. For example, an applicant might conceal a pre-existing medical condition or misrepresent their income to obtain a higher coverage amount. These misrepresentations, if they are material and made intentionally or fraudulently, can result in denied applications or death benefits, leaving the policyholder’s loved ones without the financial protection they need from a life insurance policy.

In order to prevent misrepresentation in life insurance, it’s necessary to:

  • Be honest and comprehensive when giving information about your health, lifestyle, and income
  • Communicate with your insurer if you have any questions or concerns about the application process
  • Ensure that all information provided is accurate and complete.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is an example of misrepresentation in insurance?

An example of misrepresentation in insurance can be lying about installing a swimming pool, using a friend’s or relative’s address to lower the premium, or intentionally setting fire to a property to collect a payout but filing a claim stating the fire was an accident.

When can a misrepresentation void an insurance policy?

If a misrepresentation is material, and would have led the insurer to refuse the policy if they had known about it, then the misrepresentation can void an insurance policy.

What is the lies of misrepresentation?

Misrepresentation is a false or misleading statement, or an omission of material facts, with the intent to deceive. It is one of the elements of common law fraud and other causes of action for fraud, such as securities fraud. The most serious type of misrepresentation is a fraudulent misrepresentation which involves a deliberate lie.

What are the three types of misrepresentation in insurance?

isrepresentation in insurance can take the form of innocent, negligent, or fraudulent acts.

What is the contestability period in insurance policies?

The contestability period in insurance policies is a two year duration during which insurers can review claims for any inaccuracies.

Let's Go Beyond, to Bring You Back

Let's get you the compensation you're entitled to. Get a FREE Consultation today.

Let's Go Beyond, to Bring You Back

You deserve the compensation you’re entitled to, call for your FREE Case Review today.