National Life Group Lawsuit: The Legal Claims and Consumer Implications

• An ongoing Class Action Lawsuit filed against National Life Group entities (such as Premier Financial Alliance and Life Insurance Company of the Southwest), as well as multiple National Life Group executives, for allegedly running an illegal pyramid scheme; a serious claim that has caused widespread alarm among all those associated with the insurance industry.
• While a single disgruntled party has never brought a lawsuit against National Life Group, the present case is a Class Action Lawsuit; a lawsuit that represents an entire group of Plaintiffs and addresses a pattern of conduct, rather than an isolated incident.
• The current lawsuit highlights the severity of the problem and is more than just a lawsuit against National Life Group; it has addressed the larger system-wide problems associated with the operation of a large life insurance company.

Accusations and Allegations

The lawsuit makes what can only be described as serious accusations against National Life Group. The Plaintiffs allege that National Life Group was involved in an illegal pyramid scheme that focused on recruiting individuals from vulnerable immigrant communities, including Chinese, Filipino, Vietnamese, and other Asian-American communities.

The alleged pyramid scheme required each participant to recruit six new participants and then obtain an insurance license prior to purchasing a life insurance policy. Once licensed, the recruits would then have permission to go on to recruit even more associates. The Plaintiffs claim that the primary focus of National Life Group was recruiting from immigrant communities and using affinity relationships to improperly sell Universal Life Policies. Specifically, the Plaintiffs claim that National Life Group used false or misleading representations regarding future premium payment levels to exploit the trust within these immigrant communities.

Affected Communities

As noted above, the Plaintiff’s claim is that the business model of National Life Group focused on recruiting from immigrant communities. The communities identified by the Plaintiffs as being targeted by National Life Group include:

• Chinese
• Filipino
• Vietnamese
• Other Asian-American communities

Additionally, these communities have been impacted by a complex scheme created by a major financial service company, which is involved in the sale of insurance, including life insurance.

Furthermore, the focus on these communities illustrates the degree to which National Life Group has abused the trust within these communities. In many cases, individuals from these communities who sought to protect their families financially have been caught up in a scheme that emphasized the recruitment of associates over the sale of legitimate insurance products.

Impact of the Lawsuit on Policyholders

With the allegations against National Life Group now public, policyholders are likely to experience the negative effects of the lawsuit. Lawsuits against life insurance companies often result in delays in the processing of claims, placing an undue burden on the policyholders and their families. Furthermore, policyholders may experience unethical insurance practices, such as delays in the processing of claims, lack of communication, and unexplained claim denial during the pendency of litigation.

Subsequent sections of this article will discuss the nature and extent of claim denials and delays, as well as the need for policyholders to seek legal assistance in addressing the aforementioned issues.

Claim Denials and Delays

There are several scenarios in which a life insurance company may deny a claim. One such scenario is if the insurance company asserts that the policyholder has engaged in:

• Lying on the application
• Engaged in undisclosed risky activities
• Fraud
• Undue influence
• Mental Incapacity

If an insurance company denies a claim based on these assertions, a dispute may arise between the insurance company and the policyholder regarding the validity of the claim, which may ultimately result in a denied payout to the beneficiaries of the policyholder.

Policyholders may also experience delays in the processing of claims if the insurance company engages in delay tactics, such as dragging out claims or failing to thoroughly investigate claims. Disputes may also arise when multiple parties have competing claims to a life insurance policy, delaying the distribution of the proceeds of the policy.

Legal Assistance Needed

Given the challenges listed above, policyholders may need to obtain legal assistance in addressing issues related to bad-faith insurance practices, such as unjustified claim denials based upon immigration status or other factors, as well as claim denials and delays that are not justified by the actions of the policyholder. When insurers fail to respond in a timely manner to a claim, deny claims without justification, or make low-ball settlement offers, insurance dispute lawyers are essential.

Insurance dispute lawyers at Wyly & Cook can assist in gathering evidence, demonstrating that there is no reasonable basis for the denial of a claim, and challenging denied claims on the basis of exclusions such as alcohol, suicide, or felony. We assist policyholders with delayed or denied life insurance claims, disputes between beneficiaries, interpleader lawsuits, and ERISA issue appeals on a no recovery/no fee basis. Life insurance beneficiary designations can sometimes become complicated, and therefore, some familiarity with the law governing designations in the state in which a policy is issued may be necessary.

Financial Ratings and Implications

Although National Life Group faces numerous legal challenges, the company’s financial ratings continue to be strong. An insurance company’s financial ratings reflect the rating agency’s view of the financial strength of the company and its ability to pay claims and honor contractual obligations. Currently, National Life Group’s subsidiary life insurance companies are rated as follows:

• A.M. Best rating at A+ (Superior)
• Standard & Poor’s at A+ (Strong)
• Moody’s at A1 (Good)
• Better Business Bureau at A+ (Not BBB Accredited)

Rating agencies will reassess a company’s financial ratings when a company faces legal challenges, as they assess the risk of adverse changes to the company’s financial condition and ability to meet its obligations. Although National Life Group’s financial ratings are currently strong, the outcome of the lawsuit may affect how the company is viewed in the future and may adversely affect these ratings.

Present Financial Ratings

The financial ratings of an insurer represent the rating agency’s opinion of the insurer’s financial strength and its ability to meet its policyholder and contract obligations. Fitch Ratings has assigned an ‘A’ (Strong) Insurer Financial Strength (IFS) rating to National Life Insurance Company and its wholly owned subsidiary, Life Insurance Company of the Southwest. The ‘A’ rating from Fitch indicates a strong capacity to meet policyholder and contract obligations, with a stable outlook for National Life Group.

It is also worth noting that we do not know from the data that is available today whether the lawsuit has already had a direct effect on the financial ratings of National Life Group.

Possible Effects of the Lawsuit

The current ratings notwithstanding, the lawsuit against National Life Group can harm the company’s image and increase the amount of scrutiny from regulators and rating agencies. The lawsuit can also negatively impact National Life Group’s finances, since the company may incur the cost of defending itself and/or settling or paying judgments associated with the lawsuit. Any negative impacts of the lawsuit on the company’s financial profile can negatively impact the company’s financial ratings.

Therefore, National Life Group, along with other defendants in similar situations, must carefully manage the public’s perception of them and clearly communicate with policyholders and others about the issues at hand to minimize the reputational damage and any financial strain associated with the lawsuit.

Types of Life Insurance Offered By National Life Group

National Life Group offers a number of different types of life insurance products, including:

• Term Life Insurance
• Whole Life Insurance
• Universal Life Insurance
• Indexed Universal Life Insurance
• Variable Universal Life Insurance

Depending on the needs and financial situation of the policyholder, each type of insurance product has different characteristics and benefits.

Future articles will provide more detailed information about Term Life Insurance, Whole Life Insurance, and Universal Life Insurance, so readers will be able to understand more fully the characteristics and potential benefits of these types of life insurance products sold by National Life Group.

National Life Group’s Universal Life Insurance is an innovative combination of both flexibility and long-term savings opportunities. National Life Group has many different types of universal life insurance options that include:

• AssurePlus Protector
• Horizon Universal Life Insurance
• IncomeBuilder UL
• Foundation UL
• SecurePlus Provider
• LifeCycle Solution
• FlexLife II

Each of these options was developed to help meet the individual needs of its policyholders.
In addition to offering the opportunity to grow your cash value tax deferred, these universal life policies provide you with flexible premium payments and the opportunity to increase/decrease your death benefit as needed. Indexed universal life policies, including SecurePlus Provider, LifeCycle Solution, and FlexLife II, provide the opportunity to grow your cash value based upon the performance of one or more stock market indexes and feature a guaranteed zero percent floor to protect your cash value if the indexes decline.

Optional Riders and Customizable Policies

While providing the standard insurance packages, National Life Group offers an array of optional riders that may be added to a policy to further enhance its benefits and allow policyholders to customize their coverage to meet their own unique needs, including:

• Disability Income Rider
• Waiver of Premium Rider
• Living Benefits Rider
• Accidental Death Benefit Rider
• Children’s Term Rider
• Unemployment Rider

All of these riders provide additional layers of protection and flexibility to the standard policy and enable policyholders to customize their policies to fit their own specific needs.

Group Variable Universal Life (GVUL) Insurance

National Life Group offers Group Variable Universal Life (GVUL) insurance, which is customizable to provide a variety of policy options, including tax-deferred benefits, investment options using a fixed account, and the potential to withdraw and borrow against the policy on a tax-free basis. The GVUL coverage will be adjustable throughout the policy term and will be available until the policyholder reaches age 100. The GVUL policy can be managed through an online account portal.

Living Benefit Rider

A very beneficial optional rider that is provided by National Life Group is the Living Benefit Rider. This rider provides coverage for qualifying terminal, chronic, critical illnesses or injuries. In addition to the above, this rider also provides benefits to policyholders who are diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease or Lewy Body Dementia.

The Living Benefit Rider is available with all of National Life Group’s life insurance products.

Policyholders who are terminally ill and have a GVUL policy can take advantage of the Living Benefit Rider to accelerate the death benefit and receive some of the money in advance.

The Living Benefit Rider is intended to provide a lump sum payment to aid policyholders with significant health issues and add to their peace of mind.

Additional Optional Riders

National Life Group’s term life insurance policies offer several additional optional riders, including:

• Disability Income Rider
• Waiver of Premium Rider
• Living Benefits Rider
• Accidental Death Benefit Rider
• Children’s Term Rider
• Unemployment Rider

These additional riders offer additional layers of financial security to policyholders and allow them to customize their coverage to meet their specific needs.

A new addition to National Life Group’s lineup of offerings is the fertility journey rider, which is a one-time, lump-sum Accumulation Value Credit to couples. The fertility journey rider will be automatically applied to all new eligible FlexLife policies, pending state approval.

Legal Assistance for Denied Claims

For those affected by the National Life Group lawsuit or experiencing difficulty collecting on a claim, obtaining legal representation is highly recommended. Policyholders experiencing difficulties with claim denials or delays at National Life Group should carefully document all of their interactions with the company. Maintaining a thorough file of all communication and transactions with National Life Group can be highly beneficial when resolving disputes with the company.

Wyly & Cook attorneys can utilize the documentation gathered by policyholders to represent them effectively in resolving a denied claim or lawsuit involving National Life Group.

Life Insurance Claim Dispute Attorneys

Wyly & Cook attorneys have experience representing policyholders and beneficiaries whose claims were unfairly denied or delayed by insurance companies, including National Life Group. Our attorneys have knowledge of the relevant laws and regulations governing denied or delayed insurance payments and can use this knowledge to help our clients successfully file a life insurance claim dispute lawsuit.

FAQs

Is National Life Group being sued?

Is National Life Group FDIC insured?